|
History and
Aims
Conferences and seminars
Publications
Partners
Membership
Staff
and Students
Research
Projects
Research
opportunities
in
regional history
The
Regional Historian
Local
History Events
Useful
links
|
SUFFRAGETTE PHOTOGRAPHS
Dr June Hannam, University of the West of
England
|
As a small provincial city Bath is not the sort of place that historians
would expect to find militant suffrage activity. And yet the city had a thriving
branch of the militant group, the Women’s Social and Political Union. Among its
members were Mary Blathwayt and her mother Emily who lived at Eagle House in
nearby Batheaston. Nearly all of the leading activists from the WSPU stayed at
some point in Eagle House where they could rest after exhausting speaking tours
or recuperate from their experiences of prison and forcible feeding. When they
visited the house suffragettes were encouraged to plant a tree in ‘Annie’s
Arboretum’, also known as the ‘suffragette’, field where their photographs were
taken by Mary’s father, Colonel Linley Blathwayt, who was also a supporter of
the movement. The three photographs reproduced here are from Colonel Linley’s
extensive collection. Although we know about the suffragette field and the tree
planting from documentary sources, the photographs can provide an added
dimension to our understanding of the militant movement
Edwardian suffragettes were among the first protest groups to make extensive
use of visual propaganda. Tickner has argued that the imagery of the movement
should be seen not just as an ‘illustration of the "real" political history
going on elsewhere’, but as an integral part of the conflict ‘with its own power
to shape thoughts, focus debates and stimulate action’. Women artists produced
drawings and cartoons for posters, postcards, banners and newspapers, but
photographs also had a key part to play in drawing attention to the cause. Who
can forget the striking image of Mrs Pankhurst being lifted off the ground by a
policeman as she was arrested during a demonstration outside the House of
Commons. Images such as these ensured that, while women for years were ‘hidden
from history’, this could not be said of the suffragettes who retained their
place in the history books and in popular memory. the size of the field, which
is extensive, and provides a glimpse of the summer house in which suffragettes
|
 |
Colonel Linley’s
photographs provide us with less familiar images. In the first picture Annie
Kenney watches Teresa Garnett plant a tree. Annie Kenney, a former mill
worker, was an organiser for the WSPU in the West Country and was a key
figure for the Blathwayt family. They found her to be a charismatic
personality and Mary lived with her for several months in Bristol to help
with organising work. Annie was a frequent visitor to EagleHouse, where she
had her own |
|
room, and the suffragette field was named after her. Teresa Garnett was very
active from 1909, when in that year she attacked Winston Churchill with a
riding whip in Bristol and went to prison for disturbing the peace. The
photograph is clearly staged so that the viewer gains the impression that
women who had a tree named after them actually visited the field and took an
active part in the planting. The photograph also gives a a sense of the size
of the field which is extensive, and provides a glimpse of the summer house
in which suffragettes were able to rest. The other two photographs show
Annie Kenney and Elsie Howey, one of the women who hid behind the organ in
the Colston Hall and disrupted the cabinet minister, Augustine Birrell’s
speech. They are standing by their trees, which are clearly marked with a
metal plaque, recording the species of tree, the date of planting and the
names of the women associated with the trees. The clothing worn in the
photographs provides points of interest for the
|
 |
historian In many publicity shots Annie Kenney is dressed in typical mill
workers’ clothes, such as shawl, apron and clogs, in order to emphasise that
the movement attracted women from all social classes. In the photographs
reproduced here the style of her dress and the material used is plain in
comparison to the other women, but there is no attempt to differentiate her
from the others. Indeed all of the women are wearing clothes which are
relatively simple and unostentatious. This may have been a way to draw
attention to the similarities between them, regardless of their class, and
also to indicate their seriousness of purpose. At the same time they are
depicted as ‘feminine’, in soft blouses and with their hair pinned up in the
latest fashion. Annie Kenney in particular is photographed in a |
|
conventional female pose as she gazes wistfully at her tree, holding
the top branch as gently as possible. The suffragettes were anxious to use
imagery to counter the stereotypes put forward by their opponents that they were
‘unwomanly’, ‘mannish’ or a ‘shrieking sisterhood’.As part of their own
definition of womanliness, however, they emphasised women’s ability to take
militant political action and most of their photographs depict women
engaged in direct propaganda in a public space, such as demonstrations or
selling their newspapers. The photographs reproduced here are unusual in showing
suffragettes in a more domestic space, in peaceful and contemplative mood. They
provide a reminder that suffrage campaigners also had another life in which they
socialised and stayed for weekends with friends. Suffrage work took over much of
their lives, but not all of them.
They were in fact ‘ordinary’ women engaged in extraordinary events.
Suffragettes were aware of being members of a collective group, working together
for a common cause.On the other hand the willingness of individuals to take
risks and to display courage was vital for the success of the WSPU. The
photographs draw attention to both these sides of the movement. The women wear
the purple, white and green colours of the WSPU on their brooches, while the
trees and plaques symbolise both their collective and their individual struggle.
In the pictures of Annie Kenney and Elsie Howey the trees are much taller than
those which have been recently planted which suggests that the movement was also
growing stronger and spreading. The photographs also celebrate the achievements
of individuals, in particular those who are less well known, such as Teresa
Garnett and Elsie Howey. To get a real sense of the large number of different
women involved, however, it is essential to look at the whole series of
photographs taken by Colonel Linley which provide a unique record of the rank
and file.
|

Photos reproduced by kind permission of Mary Frayling. |
It is impossible
to know whether Colonel Blathwayt ever intended that his photographs should
be published. Unlike photographs placed in the press or sold as postcards,
these were not used for direct propaganda purposes. On the other hand the
fact that they were taken suggests that even in the thick of the fight
contemporaries were aware of the historical significance of what they were
doing and wished to ensure that the individual women who took part should
not be forgotten. It is ironic that Colonel Linley sought to record the
planting of trees which he must have assumed would be a long-lasting
reminder of the actions of individual suffragettes. Instead, in the 1960s
the trees were cleared to make way for a housing estate and it is the
photographs which have remained to provide historians with a reminder of the
varied women who took part in the struggle for their rights. |
Further reading
For more on the Blathwayt family, see B.M.Willmott Dobbie, A Nest of
Suffragettes in Somerset (Batheaston Society, 1979) and J.Hannam,
‘"Suffragettes are Splendid for any Work": The Blathwayt Diaries as a Source
for Suffrage History' , in C. Eustance, J. Ryan and L. Ugolini eds., A
Suffrage Reader (Leicester University Press, 2000). For a discussion of
suffrage imagery, see L.Tickner, The Spectacle of Women: Imagery of the
Suffrage Campaign, 1907-14 (Chatto & Windus, 1987) and D.Atkinson, ‘Six
Suffragette Photographs’, in M. Joannou and J. Purvis eds., The Women’s
Suffrage Movement: New Feminist
|
|